Brooklyn Brothers Pizza

Update: 1/18/25 - Stopped in for lunch and we had a Steak & Cheese, BLT & the Fettuccine Alfredo. We all enjoyed everything and the service was amazing. This is a great pizza place that is hidden in this shopping strip. We started with the calamari, it was a little thicker than I am used to but it was still very good. I also had a Caesar salad which was very fresh. We got a 16-in sausage pepperoni mushroom and onion and it is probably one of my top five favorites in the area. I love the taste that the brick oven offers and the wait staff were very pleasant and friendly as well as top notch service. I will definitely be coming back for more.

Enjoyed the Brooklyn Special Pizza. It was a meat lovers dream. I can not remember having better. It was delicious and paired with a Ceaser Salad made for an excellent meal. Fast service, friendly staff and a comfortable family friendly atmosphere made for a very enjoyable dinner.

Stopped in for lunch. The atmosphere is nice, slightly upscale and quiet. The menu is extensive. I opted for two slices of pepperoni, their lunch suggestion. Folks, this is authentic NY style pizza! It was amazing! And the price was incredible, landing in the fast food combo range. Service was excellent and the owner was on the premises checking with folks to make sure they enjoyed their food. I’ll be back!!

I don’t often post negative reviews, but felt strongly about this isolated experience. We have dined in and gotten take out on a consistent basis since Brooklyn Brothers opened. Tonight we ordered pizza and my son ordered Spaghetti and Meatballs. The pizza was excellent, but the pasta barely had any sauce. I spoke to the server about it and she brought a small ramekin of sauce. When we got our bill, I found she charged us 85 cents for the sauce. It’s not the 85 cents, it’s the principle. I’m disappointed our server didn’t discuss this with me. I would have gladly taken this up with the manager had I been informed. I normally tip 25-30% of the taxes total. I was not as generous this evening and Brooklyn Brothers has lost a consistent customer over 85 cents.

This was my first time stopping and the pizza was a 10/10! I definitely recommend I got 2 slices of pepperoni during their lunch special and I will be returning with my family. If you’re in the area and want good pizza this is the place!