Brooklyn Born - Iconic Famous Coal Fired Brick Oven Pizzeria ™

Was feeling famished after 85 miles of cycling. Passed by here many times and always wanted to give it a try. The urge was unbearable today due to the stomach growls. Walked in and was going to order 2-3 slices but then was informed they only serve pies. “I can eat a horse” as the saying goes. So I’m game. Asked what was popular and was told “the Margherita Pie for $25.” After being told it only takes 5 minutes preparation. I’m sold! Fastest service ever. It only took 20 seconds for the pie to land in my hands after placing the order. One just came out of the oven and they decided to give it to me first since the customer hasn’t arrived yet. 🙏🏻🙏🏻 I picked up a slice right there and ate it on the way to the garage. By the time I placed the box in the front seat, I got to working on a 2n

My girl used to dine here as a child, often with her family. She hyped the place up and was very excited to live out her past. When we arrived, we were seated quickly. Our pizza came out within 5 mins of ordering which was extremely quick to which the server responded “I told them to rush it”. That was fine, as we were both starving. However the pizza looked sad. It was very soggy and the cheese had no pull. She took one bite and couldn’t finish the slice. There was no truffle flavor either. We realized that the pizza came out so fast because it was not freshly prepared and had been sitting already. We could be completely wrong about this but that was the impression the pizza gave us, due to the composition of the cheese. My girl sent it back and a fresh pie was made. It was much better

Solid brick oven pizza! We ordered one margarita pizza and one with mushrooms both were really tasty. I really like the crust it's thin and crispy with a great sauce. I give the margarita a 7.5/10 and the mushroom pizza 7.8/10. It's definitely going to be in my pizza rotation. Only complaint is I ordered a few cans of coke $3 a can is too expensive.

Good pizza but be aware for delivery! $35 pizza comes in brown bag, can’t afford a decent card board box. Always cold! Can’t even reheat because it’s already charred!

The staff is very nice and welcoming . The pizza was very delicious I can’t wait to visit again!!