Bronx Pizza & Pints

I swear I left a review, but apparently only on Yelp 🤪. Sorry! 😢 We dined here for the first time September 2025 based on my Nextdoor Neighbors app recommendations. Being Wisconsinites, we are biased when it comes to pizza 🍕😂. When we arrived the place was packed but the hostess made a table for us😊. We ordered a 14” (thin crust only available) version of their NY style pizza (not NY). Yes the outside crust is perfectly crispy until midway then a softer texture to “fold” and eat. Very tasty👍. I also ordered the 3 mini cannoli’s, but not up to my Italian standards, unfortunately. The service was great (Becca😊), pricing affordable, everything homemade/fresh ingredients, a very good first time experience. We’ve been dining there now ever since. I’ve been trying their various desserts and can

So many positive things to talk about with this place: the pizza is delicious, definitely be prepared to take some home. They have really good cocktails and a full bar, and TVs for sports all around. The owners gave us the opportunity to have my son's birthday at the restaurant, and provided 8 kids with dough to play with and toss around, plus individual personal pizzas that they were able to add ingredients to. Incredible customer service--we took up several tables on Valentine's day for the birthday, and Justin was out there showing the kids how to toss the dough and make their pizzas perfect. Don't sleep on this one, it's a neighborhood gem run by people who believe in community!

Our 3rd visit to this place. We've gotten something different every time and its all been amazing! 🤌 Endless options to create your own pizza, and by the slice too! Their long Island iced tea is the bomb!

Pretty good pizza. Although ours could have maybe come out of the oven a minute earlier, the edges were a little too crispy for our taste. The fried pickles were amazing. We will be back!

Me and the buddies rolled in after 18 holes of golf. Decided to order seperate 14" pizzas and share a slice amongst each other... this place is awesome 👌🏽. The empire, Buffalo, pestoroni and Brooklyn were delicious, the staff was great and the beers were cold. Will be back 🫡