Brewster Pizza House & Sports Bar

I don't like to write negative reviews on small businesses but wow, this pizza was horrible. The pizza was so bad it actually felt insulting, like it felt personal. I'll attach a photo to show you. It's been a week since we ate here and it's still on my mind. It was expensive too. I expected a much better slice at that price. It's disappointing.

Lack of communication with server/bar staff. Asked if we wanted a menu, we did. After looking at the menu and deciding on food for ten mins, when we told bar server what we wanted they said they only had pizza. 🙄 could have told us that when you handed us the menus. Table next to us ordered a calzone, got served a pizza. And then a more burnt pizza came out later. They wanted over an hour for it!! Dirty bathrooms also. Will not be returning. Too bad. We have a house right down the street that we rent.

My wife and I ate there last night in the bar it took about an hour to get a small pizza and a Greek salad. (We were the only ones there) The pizza was cold and the salad was basically lettuce on a plate. The bartender sat on his phone while loudly sniffling (he had a runny nose) and seemed indifferent about how long it was taking for our order to arrive. Never again. Btw, bathrooms are filthy.

Literally some of the best pizza I’ve never had. Idk how they have bad reviews. We did a take out and were very satisfied by the pizza and bread sticks. Highly recommended.

Great Greek pizza! All of the food is really tasty and the food came out so hot when we dined in. The pizza is cheesy and delicious. The onion rings are thin and crispy which I find to be unique but really yummy. Luke helped us and he was so friendly and sweet! Brewster pizza is a Cape Cod summer go-to for our fam!