Brewster Pastry

Cute pastry shop with amazing, homemade pastries. Their peach cake is to die for. As of this review, coffee is still a buck, and quite good! Super friendly service, take out only.

fruit tarts may have mold! sad because they tasted good until we saw it, powdered sugar made it hard to see it but glad we noticed it! also the cheescake was very lemony and on a vanilla cake base instead of graham cracker which seemed odd - lady behind the counter refused to write my dad’s happy birthday message in red and then wrote it in blue because he’s a boy…even though red is his favorite color, had to redo it when i got home.

I am SUPER late as always but wanted to thank BSP again for my perfect wedding cake!! It was extremely hot that day so these pictures only show but so much of this beauty. Our guests loved the red velvet, thank you thank you!!

They made our wedding cake for a small wedding dinner we had with 40 people to celebrate our elopement. The cake was absolutely beautiful and tasted even better. It was exactly what I wanted and the cost was more than worth it!

Every dessert I have ever bought from Brewster Pastry has been amazing! Most recently I ordered a carrot cake for my husband's birthday and everyone agreed it was the MOST DELICIOUS carrot cake we had ever had! It was fresh, moist, not too sweet, and had the perfect amount of cream cheese icing and filling. It was also decorated beautifully!