Bono's Pizzeria

My new go-to pizza place. The tomato sauce is exceptional, and theres something about the crust thats better than anything else ive tasted. My go-to is always a sausage and pepper slice, and a Meatball slice. Keep up the good work! 👌

When you are going to make Sicilian Baked Ziti, and you decide to make it entirely different from the rest of the world (please google search Sicilian Baked Ziti), maybe you should list that there is chicken in it instead of eggplant. This was an entire wasted dish of food as we cannot eat it. The real disappointment is the lack of accountability in either a correct replacement or a refund (according to Slice on your behalf). It honestly doesn't seem worth the loss of our weekly business (and this honest and accurate review), as we rather enjoyed your pizza, but you reap what you sow. Recommendation: Add some descriptions to your menu (its lacking) if you're going to do your own take of established dishes. Absolute disappointment. Here's a picture of an almost perfect Sicilian Baked Ziti

Bono’s pizzeria is hands down the best pizza spot on Long Island. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with friendly service and welcoming atmosphere. The pizza is always fresh, perfectly cooked (especially when you ask for well done) and full of flavor. You can really tell they use high quality ingredients. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering for the whole family, everything is consistently delicious. Highly recommend Bono’s Pizzeria to anyone looking for amazing pizza and great service. We’ll definitely be coming back.

I've been going to Bono's since the mid-late 90's and when I randomly popped up there several years ago the owners still remembered me from when me and my friends went there in high school! Since then I've put lots of my friends on to this wonderful place! They're consistent if nothing else... same fantastic food same courteous service! They're sons work there now and they've done an excellent job carrying on tradition the Italian way! Always get my service with a smile just as their pops and uncle did. Hands down the best pizza in Bay Shore for the past 30 years or so!! Go down there and grab your slice or pie today!

I’ve been coming to Bonos for a very long time. Every-time I go in I get myself a personal well done pie. They always know how to accomplish that!!! Highly recommend coming here family owned and overall amazing food and great company when if you choose to sit down and eat there!