Boniello's

So many tempting dishes on the menu, plus the secret menu, make it hard to decide what to try. They have angel hair pasta, a personal fav, cooked al dente with a nice marinara. The Rafael personal 12" margarita (sp?) with ricotta stuffed crust sprinkled with toasty sesame seeds was worth the wait, crusty on the outside, melted mozzarella, fresh basil on top. Canoli tasted weird though, and the tiramisu could be boozier. BYOB. Service was attentive and amiable.

The food at Boniello’s is always great we’ve never had anything that didn’t taste good. That’s why this is so disappointing. Takeout service is consistently slow and disorganized. Calling in an order often means being put on hold forever, and when you arrive there’s frequently no one working the takeout counter. We’ve waited 30+ minutes after being told food was ready more times than we can count. Today was the final straw. DoorDash said the food was ready, but my husband waited over 26 minutes to receive it. The food was cold when he got home, and there was no apology. The manager we spoke to was dismissive and had an attitude. We want to support local businesses, but great food isn’t worth this level of unreliable service.

I've loved in Riverdale now for 5 years and never even noticed this place. A friend of ours mentioned she's been working part time for them forever and so we booked our 5 year old's (family) birthday dinner there. Rustic look with a local vibe; it's BYOB - sign your cork and stick it in the wall - come find it next time you dine-in. Boniello's has the best pizza in the area and the portions remind me of Carmine's in NYC. Great atmosphere, great food, and tremendous value.

I hosted my Christmas party at Boniellos and it was better than I could’ve imagined. From the second you walk in you can feel the positive energy from each and every person who works there and it radiates to the customers. We had a blast Bianca and 2 other girls were our servers and they did not miss. The food is also amazing I’m obsessed with their Chicken francese and they have lots of vegan options :) Thanks so much for having us we will be back next year.

we absolutely love boniellos and use them to cater most of our holidays! bianca is not only the sweetest person but always does an incredible job with our catering orders. we are so grateful for their amazing food, service, accuracy, and how easy they make the holidays for us, highly recommend!