Blue Star Cafe

First time there and glad I stopped in earlier today. The location is a easy to miss, but once inside it’s comfortable and homey. It feels more like a fast-food spot than a formal restaurant, even though they do have waiters. The staff was very pleasant and attentive, checking to make sure everything was to our liking. I ordered scrambled eggs and a Nutella coffee, and our group shared nachos — all of which were delicious, very fresh, and full of authentic flavor. Looking forward to coming back again soon. Go support small businesses!

This is a great place. I've eaten in all the kosher spots in the Teaneck area and this one has the most authentic and home cooked feeling of all of them for a Breakfast /Lunch spot. Have been here multiple times and have always left happy whether eating in or taking out. The prices are very reasonable and they have a kid friendly menu. Highly recommend

Came here (after a quick Google search for Kosher food) the morning after a wedding in the area. Best culinary decision I’ve made all year. They will make you anything you want (within reason) even if not on the menu. I grew up in Texas not keeping kosher, and have been craving good Mexican food - something not common in NYC or on the kosher restaurant circuit. I asked for a breakfast burrito with relatively low expectations, given the above. They knocked it out of the park. Just like I remember, if not better. I guess I should not have been surprised given the chef is a veteran from Oaxaca. Fresh coffee, friendly service, and attention to detail - they even use Mexican-inspired ceramic mugs and plates. Run, don’t walk, here. I’m honestly considering having them cater my simchas in Brookly

I have gone several times and have enjoyed the food each time. I have a family member who is on a restricted diet (low sodium and low sugar) and the staff of the cafe was so understanding about this. Everything was delicious from the cheese quesadillas, frappes, and the vegan chicken caesar wraps. Everything tasted freshly made and flavorful. I highly recommend trying the Tres Leches cake for dessert.

We went yesterday to celebrate my mother’s birthday, and this Kosher dairy Mexican restaurant absolutely exceeded our expectations. The food was authentic, fresh, and genuinely delicious — every dish felt thoughtfully made and full of flavor. The owner was incredibly friendly and accommodating, and went out of his way to help make the celebration feel special. It’s rare to find a place that combines warm hospitality with such high-quality kosher Mexican cuisine. We left so happy and can’t wait to come back!