Blue Sheep Bake Shop

I’ve always known blue sheep had delicious desserts so I hired them for my daughters first birthday. I love that the owner works directly with you and provides white glove service. She’s so accommodating and flexible to fit your needs. She made it so easy so I could focus on planning the rest of my party. And my dessert table was gorgeous (cake, cupcakes, hand piped cookies). So many people were asking me where the cake was from telling me how amazing it was. I will absolutely be using them for every important event going forward. Thank you Karen for a wonderful experience!

A must that we had for our wedding was an ice cream wedding cake. And we got it. And we have no regrets because it was so beautiful and delicious!! Thank you Karin for working with us! We loved it and wish we could eat it all over again. The communication process, pickup, looks, and taste of the cake were all perfect! This cake wasn't intended to feed all of our guests, since we had a dessert spread instead. It was mostly for us and whoever else wanted a slice so we kept it to a one tier cake. We did do one of the shop's designs because it was exactly what we wanted. It was funny because our "cake tasting" was just heading to the shop and getting a scoop of every flavor we considered. It was a fun date day. If you're also thinking about an ice cream wedding cake, DO IT.

Blue Sheep Bake Shop is the best! I requested a custom cake to celebrate my son’s graduation from the Cape May Police Academy. The baker, Karin , collaborated with me professionally and creatively, to bring to life the most amazing cake that tasted even better than it looked! All the guests raved about the cake and cupcakes. Many inquiries for the bake shop….referrals given. I will definitely be ordering from Blue Sheep again. Thank you again for all your hard work and awesome baking skills.

Cannot say enough good things! Karin was friendly and responsive. The cake looked AMAZING and was delicious too. People could not stop talking about how great it looked and tasted.

I would give Karin and her staff a hundred stars if I could! Karin has made two Italian rainbow cookie cakes, a custom Louis Vuitton birthday cake, and custom corporate cookies for me in the past year. Every time I emailed Karin, she was responsive, kind, and patient with understanding and implementing the design I was looking for. She is now my go-to for any desserts. Thanks again for always taking care of me!