Billy Goat Island Pizza Bar

Best Pizza within 50+ miles. You simply won’t find a better pizza around. Great wings too. Top it off with a beautiful lake & marina setting. Chad, Kelly & staff were great and very hospitable to my family & I. We’ll be back!

Chad and Kelly are the best. They’re making delicious pizza and wings (Chad is the chicken wing king) are on the menu by July 4th. We tried the cheese and white pizza. The white was out of this world good, we will be back for sure l. Recommend this local favorite to everyone on the lake!!

We go here quite frequently, we have taken our Youth group to enjoy the pizza and the lake. It is great to go somewhere that has Gluten Free pizza that doesn’t look like a personal pan pizza. Their flavors are so good, we have not been disappointed!! Great job guys!

Billy Goat Island Pizza is that fun local spot you find yourself craving all week long. Chad and Kelly have created a place that feels relaxed and welcoming the second you walk in. It is the kind of pizza joint where you can roll in after a day on the water, grab a table with your people, and just enjoy really great food in a laid back atmosphere. The star of the show for me is the Farmers Cheese Dip. Wowzer. It is one of those appetizers you think you are going to share, then suddenly you are guarding it with your life. And the Billy Goat pizza with hot honey is next level. Omg. Perfectly balanced, a little sweet, a little heat, and so much flavor. It is easily one of my favorite pizzas anywhere. It is also the best place to watch football. Game days here are so much fun. Great energy a

Wood fired pizza tasted amazing! Lots of fresh toppings and bursting with flavor. Beautiful setting on the water. Must try!!