Bethany’s cakes & cupcakes

This was the first time trying Bethany's. I was in a rush and ordered very last minute and she got me in. But I ordered black forest cupcakes for my son's birthday and they didn't disappoint. Not only was she fast in preparing them but the nicest person that I've talked to in customer service in a very long time. These cupcakes were heavenly. My son his friends loved them. Most falling apart just like a cupcake should. And packed with cherry filling. She even added jam under the icing. I definitely will be a repeat customer. Thank you so much for making my little mans surprise the best it could be ❤️❤️

Found Bethany's while searching for custom cakes near Timberline Mountain. With just a one week notice, Bethany and her team made us an incredible one-of-a-kind birthday cake, with matching gluten-free cupcakes! We provided pretty limited inspiration and really trusted their team to get creative for us. They did a great job and everyone loved it! Fair pricing and friendly communication. Would recommend to anyone looking for a custom cake in the Canaan Valley area.

I ordered the 6 inch red velvet cake at a $40 ticket. I don't know why or what happened but it was absolutely the worst cake I have ever had. Very very heavy and dry. Way too much red food coloring, so bad that I still taste the bitterness from food color hours after eating it. The two layer small cake was also lop sided and leaning worse than the Tower of Pisa. I will say without a doubt it was not a freshly made cake. Will never do that again. $40 for such a small cake and it was horrible to boot. Complete waste of money. It was a birthday cake too. Such disappointment.

The nachos and BBQ was incredible! The chocolate raspberry cupcake was the best thing I have ever eaten!! I will absolutely be back. SO good!

Got two pumpkins roll my my they are delicious