Benny Tudino's

Came here on a recommendation from someone that seemed like he knew what he was talking about when it came to pizza—and wow, did this place deliver. Yes, the slices are massive. Like “bigger than my head” massive. But this isn’t just about size. The pizza is legit. Perfect fold. Great structure. Nicely charred bottom. Real ingredients. Greasy in the best possible way. The pepperoni was excellent, but the anchovy + pineapple slice? Honestly one of the best slices I’ve ever had. Salty, sweet, balanced—absolutely outstanding. Had a limoncello too (which I normally don’t even like), and somehow… loved it here. Great food. Great people. Great experience. If you’re in Hoboken and love real pizza, don’t miss this place. I’ll be back. Many times.

I have been coming here since i was little with my dad. Always had great pizza! Love this place! Although yesterday i went in for a pick up thru doordash around 7pm and the guy working was so rude. I walked up and he was on his phone and i politely waited for him to turn around and i said hi picking up a doordash order of two slices and he just made a face at me and dropped the pizza box on the counter and continued with what he was doing. So rude, sadly i did not get his name. No manners whatsoever. But besides that the food is great 🍕 and past service was always great. Yesterday not so much

Absolutely outstanding! From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel welcome and treated us like family. The pizza was perfect—crispy on the outside, soft and flavorful on the inside, with the freshest toppings. You can really taste the quality ingredients and the care they put into every pie. We also tried a few sides, and everything was just as delicious. Service was quick, friendly, and attentive without ever feeling rushed. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it just as great for a casual night out as it is for take-out at home. Hands down one of the best pizza spots around—I’ll definitely be coming back regularly. Highly recommend

Benny's pizzeria used to be the best pizza in Hoboken. Ever since he sold it, the pizza is horrible instead of white onions, they put red onions, lot of red sauce and Hardly, no cheese. Look at pictures, even adding extra cheese in my house it doesn't taste good.

Had my first giant slice yesterday and I will definitely be back soon! Benny Tudinos takes pride in its pizza and it shows. The anchovies were perfectly placed to make every bite perfect and I really appreciated it. Be sure to bring cash.