Ben & Jay's Pizzeria

We came for lunch at opening time on a Saturday and the entire experience far surpassed my expectations. First, the menu options are great. We got a kickin’ chicken pizza and a cheese pizza as well as a gyro- which was one of the best I have had locally. Service was great, the restaurant is beautiful and clean, and we will absolutely return.

Hidden gem in Lawton that feels like home the moment you walk in ,I was delivering a DoorDash order and picked up a salad for a customer , it looked so fresh! 🥗 Everything was colorful, crisp, and neatly packed, and the order was ready right on time. You can tell they care about presentation and quality, not just speed. The restaurant itself has a cozy, welcoming vibe. The red awning and “We Are Family” sign outside fit perfectly with the friendly service inside. Even during busy hours, staff stays polite, quick, and organized. ✅ Fresh, flavorful ingredients ✅ Clean and inviting atmosphere ✅ Friendly staff who greet you with a smile ✅ Fast pickup and accurate orders If their salad looked that good, I can only imagine how amazing the pizza and wings are! Definitely a spot I’ll be trying

We got our order to go but inside was nice. We got the Santa Fe, ricotta be kidding me, a cheese pizza for the kids and the pizza rolls. Absolutely amazing. All of it is delicious. Wish I would have taken photos before we ate it. So very happy to have found this place.

The food came out piping hot and (more importantly) tasted amazing! We got a variety of foods: fried pickles, buffalo wings, pizza, and pasta and nothing disappointed. It’s a quaint little brick building with a lot of charm. We liked it a lot and will definitely be back.

Recently ordered food from Ben and Jay’s and we were less than impressed. Don’t get me wrong, the food was decent but really not worth what they charge. We ordered the kids chicken fingers for our daughter and they were so unbelievably dry it was like trying to tear apart jerky. Our pizza and fries were cold despite the fact we received our food in less than an hour. The pretzel sticks were warm and 10/10 though. Overall, not the worst experience we’ve ever had, but also nothing to write home about. This is just our opinion based off our experience though.