Bellia's Pizza II Elizabethtown

I rarely give five stars, but this place truly deserves it. We drove from Hershey looking for good pizza, and this gem is only about 15 minutes away, well worth the drive. The staff was super friendly, and the restaurant was clean and cozy. The pizza was amazing! We ordered the stuffed shells, Margherita pizza, and the Volcano pizza, and everything was delicious. Even though it’s a bit of a drive, we’re more than willing to make it again for such great pizza 😊

Fantastic toasted Sicilian sub which included hot capicola. All three team members worked well in concert and especially appreciate the extra effort from Patrick and the owner. Also tried a slice of cheese and it was excellent. Saw a nearby Stromboli, which I think I will get next time

October 2025, I tried Bellia's for the first time. The pizza was prepared perfectly. The salad is ordered was large and fresh vegetables. The service was excellent very friendly staff. I absolutely recommend eating here.

Excellent food with a wide variety of Italian American fare. Excellent pizza. Great sandwiches. Decent American grill style table seating with a large TV. Order at the counter and then dine in or take out. Order in advance for pickup. We were not greeted when we entered the place and there was some uncertainty in finding the menu. (Menus are on the counter). No clear sign or individual directed the process. Once situated and the order placed the service was quick. The food was fantastic.

First time visiting this location. We’ve been to the other Bellia’s and loved it, so we figured we’d give this one a shot while in the area. The place was very clean and cozy. The food came out hot and fresh. It was all very, very good. If we are ever in the area, we would return.