Barnegat Bay Ice Cream

Cute and delicious! Definitely worth the stop. We tried the Brownie Bay Volcano and Nutella Sundae. Great serving size, priced well. The Nutella sundae was very rich and the Brownie Bay Volcano was a balance of yumminess. They have Wheel chair accessibility with the ramp and convenient parking in the back. Plenty of shaded tables on the patio to enjoy your treat. Service was pleasant and quick - we’ll definitely be back!🍨

Had soft serve ice cream.... they only had vanilla n chocolate (or a mix) but it was delish. Very good prices. I got my granddaughter a small cone. It was a very nice size (larger than I expected) for only $3.75. Also ordered a kids cone and it came w a cup so they don't drip all over AND there was almost the same amount of ice cream as a small cone. They had a nice selection of hard ice cream for .25 more. They had sundaes available as well as milkshakes, banana splits, etc...see photo...

We ordered. Large sundae with hot fudge & chocolate sprinkles and no whip cream. They give us sundae with whip cream. Than the kid tried to scrape it off. They finally gave us new ice cream but it was the size of a small to medium size ice cream cup. For $5.00. My banana split looked like a total mess. Kids that work there seemed to be overwhelmed. We’ll be going back up Manahawkin ice cream.

I have got ice cream from Barneget Ice Cream with my family for years. The ice cream is amazing. Reasonably priced, portion sizes are large ( which is a good thing ), and a wide varietie of flavors. Each flavor is rich and filled with flavor. For example when you get birthday cake ice cream it’s not just vanilla ice cream with sprinkles it actually tastes like birthday cake. Highly Recommend!!

5 stars because it’s looked so inviting and clean. Support local business! Prices look good too. Good flavour ice cream and water ice. Plenty of parking and nice sitting area.