Baldwin Pizzeria

I’ve been going to Baldwin Pizza since 1989, and it’s still just as good as I remember. The pizza is great, the people are awesome, and even with a couple of ownership changes over the years, the food has stayed consistently solid. I moved across town a while back, but anytime I’m in the area, I make a point to stop in and grab a few slices or a couple of pies. The crust is slightly crispy with just the right light crunch, not hard. Really delicious pizza and a longtime local favorite of mine.

First time trying Balvin Pizza and it was a great surprise. After eating thin crust from Papa John’s for almost 10 years, I decided to give this place a try—and I’m glad I did. The pizza was fresh, perfectly crispy, and loaded with fresh toppings. You can really taste the quality. The owner even gave me a complimentary item, which was a very kind gesture. Everyone there was friendly and welcoming. I left really happy. If you love great pizza and great service, you should definitely try this place!”

Great for a quick bite ! I asked them to sprinkle some crushed red pepper and oregano on my pizza while it baked that I picked up and they sprinkled just the right amount !!! Added some more recent pictures. We're still ordering Baldwin Pizza 📌

(EDIT: After ordering last week, we ordered again last night. Got the same items as the first time - and they were still absolutely awesome (kudos to the restaurant for their attention to quality and consistency!) - plus added a Chicken Milanase sub also, and I can tell you it was a great choice! Super fresh and tasty and very well put together! Certainly getting it next time too!) INITIAL REVIEW: I had the food from Baldwin Pizzeria once previously when a friend of mine was kind enough to bring my wife and I both a platter of a grilled chicken sandwich with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and balsamic with fries each. We liked it so much that we inquired about where it was from. Tonight we got around to finally ordering so we could try some other dishes. I didn't realize how late it wa

Saved My Night & Won My Heart! I was having the worst day ever—one of those days where everything goes wrong and the last thing you want to do is cook. I happened to be right around the corner from this hometown pizzeria as they were just about to close. On a whim, I called and asked if they had any slices left—and if there was any chance they’d stay open for just two more minutes so I could grab one. To my surprise, they said yes! Not only did they wait for me, but the hospitality I received was above and beyond anything I expected. The guy with the beard (if you know, you know) was incredibly kind and welcoming. He truly made my night—and he didn’t even know it. And the pizza? Absolutely delicious. Fresh, flavorful, and exactly what I needed in that moment. You can tell it’s made with lo