Baggby's Gourmet Sandwiches

Stopped in to grab some sandwiches for myself and kids on the way to the children’s museum. It was fantastic! Everything was made fresh to order and the service was excellent. Inside was cozy, but we chose to sit out front in the nice weather. Excellent sandwiches and would try again!

I am obsessed with the Philly cheesesteak with jalapeños in it. I keep coming back every week to get this sandwich after I came for the first time a couple weeks ago, it might just be my favorite Philly cheesesteak ever!! Also the owner is really kind and fun to talk to. You can tell he really cares about his customers and remembers your name if you show up a few times!

First time trying Baggby’s but huge fan! It’s so delicious and fresh. They had our order ahead of 13 sandwiches ready 5 minutes early and correct. Super delicious and recommend

Highly recommend the Grinder. It’s the last picture in the sequence. I got the Baggby’s club on sourdough and it was delightful. If you want a classic sandwich this is they way to go! Now, the Grinder is next level. It the classic Italian sandwich taken to the next level. They have fresh lemonade, nothing else to say about that. Just get it! We all got our kids a classic grilled cheese and pbj and it was nothing short of great! We had a good conversation with the owner and his family. He shared some hidden gems with us to make our time around the area better.

I was underwhelmed. With all the hype for these sandwiches, I wasn’t impressed with the way my sandwich turned out - it tasted like a sandwich I could get from a school cafeteria with basic ingredients. As a sandwich-lover, even for a basic turkey sandwich there are ways to make it taste delicious. I got a turkey sandwich and a pastrami sandwich, and both were not very flavorful or memorable. The pastrami in particular didn’t have the classic pastrami taste that I was looking for. They do have a nice selection of chips and drinks though, cookies too, so those can supplement the sandwich. Another tip, if you do plan to go for lunch, Expect to wait a long time - it seems they’re understaffed so I recommend ordering a while ahead of time and being patient. They’re working as hard as they ca