Bagel Lovers

I have lived in Arizona since 2000, I moved from East Quogue, and worked in Riverhead for over 15 years. I ate at Bagel Lovers for lunch every single day I worked in Riverhead. I miss it so so much!! Sure there’s good food here in AZ. However once you cross the Mississippi, the water is different and good bagels out here do not exist. I would seriously consider flying back for Bagel Lovers once a month if I could afford it!!! I miss this gem at least once a week for the past 26 years that’s how good Bagel Lovers is.

A few months ago I would have given 10 stars, but the last gew times I've ordered food, it was a not disappointing. I'm not sure if there is a new cook, but the quality is down. How does one ask for extra mayo and barely any on it. Every time! I really hope they do better, my wife and I used to enjoy their food!!

What a terrific place. It is like stepping back in time to the fifties in a good way. Lots of seating and the bagels are out of this world. Fresh and with just the right balance of soft and chewy. The staff literally fall over backwards to please. I have tried a few different variants but my go to order is just a simple egg and ham on an everything bagel with a large coffee. Yum,yum. Parking lot a little small but you can park in the street if you have to. Last time we had a group of 10 and no one was disappointed. Give it a shot!

I have been going to bagel lovers for about 2 years plus, Denise and Kenny run a great bagel place with great food and a great atmosphere. They also can make anything you want just need to ask...I even have my own sandwich there.

Absolutely wonderful place to spend your mornings getting coffee and a sandwich before work. Incredibly cozy, and the staff are all extremely good people. I love this place with my heart and soul.