Bagel Buzz

I contacted Bagel Buzz to cater a brunch to entertain family coming to visit from Idaho. They requested the best New York bagels since good bagels are hard to find in Idaho. I also have severe food allergies in my family which includes peanuts, tree nuts, strawberries and red dye #40. I spoke with Gina who was a delight! She took my allergy request very serious and assured me that no cross contamination would take place. She got back to me quickly with a very very reasonable price! It was delivered on time. The salad wrap platter looked and tasted amazing. The bagels my Idaho family requested did not disappoint. Everything was delicious and fresh. You owe it to yourself to let Bagel Buzz in West Islip cater your next event.

I went to Bagel Buzz for my first time today and I’m extremely disappointed. The staff there was very friendly. However the bagels I got were all underbaked. I’ve never had a Long Island bagel undercooked before. It resulted in the bagel being wildly gummy. I’d go somewhere else.

I happened to see this place after leaving the doctors office near by. Had a pastrami,Swiss on rye. Absolutely fantastic. And a cup of coffee which was also delicious. I'd frequent this deli/bagel place more often but unfortunately I live many many miles from there.

This is the second time that they have messed up our order. Ordered a BLT and got bacon on a bagel which I wouldn’t mind but not only is it the wrong item but the bagel taste like dirty water. Disgusting! I called and they said they would give me a credit that’s nice but they can keep it cause we will never order from them again.

First time and last time going here - my wrap was soggy drenched in oil and the avocado in my wrap tasted terrible - this is borderline expired and practically black. I’m not one to complain or do reviews but whoever made this flat out doesn’t care