Badass Bagels Rye

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Badass Bagels lives up to the name in every way. The bagels are perfectly toasted with that ideal crunch on the outside and soft chew inside. The avocado spreads are fresh, generously layered, and beautifully seasoned, and the egg salad and smoked whitefish options look just as dialed in. The coffee and cold drinks menu is on point from cold brew to hibiscus iced tea and lemonade everything feels thoughtfully curated. The space itself is clean, modern, and welcoming, with great natural light and a relaxed neighborhood vibe. Even the merch and packaged goods add to the personality of the place. You can tell quality and detail matter here. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or sitting down to enjoy it, this spot delivers consistently. Easily a go-to bagel stop in Rye. Highly recom

If you're looking to try something new then look no further. This unique bagel shop adds a twist with your usual bagel catalog, from unique butters and spreads to diverse bagels, this is not your average bagel shop. The staff was very friendly and the storefront had a punk-rustic atmosphere. I enjoyed a everything sourdough bagel with a plain cream cheese which is much smoother than most. While priced at $6 a little more than I would like to spend, it was enjoyable none the less. I will be back and be bold to try one of their different bagels and or spreads. Much luck to the owners and their future in Rye.

Lived in Rye for most of my life. Best bagels around Westchester. Period. Healthy, fresh and no BS - my favorite! I got their poppyseed bagel with scallion cream cheese and it was delicious. I didn’t get a chance to snap a photo but let me tell you, the bagel to go box is licked clean. I highly recommend this place. My one constructive criticism would be maybe to have on some light music on the inside. Other than that 10/10!!

Updated (1/26): I came back to give this place another shot and the bagel while still expensive was improved. The cookie I added to my order however had huge pieces of parchment paper baked into it and I practically ate two of them! I wish I could say they fixed the operational issues but I’m afraid this place is still a risk to eat at and I don’t plan to return a third time. Added photo of cookie with paper. Original Review: Good news: The flavors are interesting and it’s new so it gets a pass on some things. Bad news: my bagel was very undercooked in one spot(hard to see in the photo) and the hot honey pistachio cream cheese just tastes like jalapeños and pickles. I hope this team turns up the operations dial because the menu and location show promise. Prices also need to come a bit b

Badass Bagels lives up to its name—the bagels and spreads are truly unique and some of the best I’ve had in the area. That said, the shop in Rye is still finding its footing operationally. The staff is always friendly, but the process can feel a bit chaotic, even when there aren’t many customers waiting. A little more efficiency would go a long way in improving the experience. I’d definitely recommend grabbing some bagels and spreads to prepare and enjoy at home. The shop has a minimalist aesthetic that aligns with the brand, but it doesn’t feel like a place designed for lingering. The quality of the bagels makes it well worth a visit!