Athenian Garden

Absolutely the best!!! We moved out of New Jersey twelve years ago after Sandy, but we keep coming back here. Family atmosphere with friendly attentive service. Make sure you check hours open before you go through.

Worst experience ever — and I didn’t even have to step foot in the restaurant. When calling about our reservation, the lady on the phone was extremely rude and condescending. When I asked to push our reservation back by an hour, she responded unprofessionally, making comments about our party being “big” and saying our children “should be controlled,” which was completely inappropriate. She then claimed she still needed time to cook the food and said we hadn’t given her enough time, even though we were simply requesting a later reservation. Instead of trying to work with us or communicating respectfully, she abruptly said she would “just cancel the reservation.” Just speaking to someone like this over the phone was enough to completely turn me off from ever wanting to try this place. Cus

They had the nicest staff here and everything was made fresh to order!! Im pretty sure it was family run so it was a nice place to stop at for dinner and I would definitely recommend coming here for large portions!!!

Very glad I finally checked this place out . The food was great ! Really enjoyed the space ! Great friendly staff . Can definitely tell it’s family run which is nice to see .. the food was fresh . Made to order . I did not mind waiting one bit . Nice to have the food made to order. Will definitely be going back often to try the other items on the menu .

One of the last of its kind ! True family run authentic restaurant… exquisite is an appropriate description .. the half roast chicken made me moan