Arrenello's Pizza

My family & love this pizza however tonight it was not it. The pizza was also suppose to have red peppers which it did not. I asked for it to be well done & it was a sloppy mess. I have had this issue before missing the red peppers or not being well done. Most of the time I call to make an order and they pick up & right away place on hold, very rude & sometimes don’t answer & it’s during operating hours. It's upsetting because I pay for something and don't get that. Food: 1/5 | Service:

I stumbled upon this place on accident trying to get around a freight train. I use to love sweet sauce pizza from pizzahut 15 years ago. So I thought what the heck majority of the reviews says it's really sweet. I enjoy sweet things so it shouldn't be a problem. WRONG. When I received the pizza hot and fresh it was very very sweet. The sweetness overpowered any other taste. It wasn't like a sweet taste like candy. It was like a sweet taste of to much sugar and now it taste bad with a after taste. I struggled to eat this pizza but I paid for it so I was forcing it down my throat. I ordered a small sasuage which came out to $17 which is expensive for the tiny pizza i received. I did end up having left overs which I threw into the air fryer the next day. On the leftovers I added red pep

Not sure if this was an off night or a recipe change, but the sauce tastes different. My family has been eating this pizza for over 20 years and we LOVE the sweet sauce. However, tonight the sauce was super watery and not sweet at all. Hopefully it’s back to normal next time. We’ve never had a bad pizza until tonight.

Their pizza is always good. I've been coming here for over 5 years and the sweet sauce has not changed. Great Customer Service. Our family thin crust pizza are about $30-$35

Out of All the pizza joints in the area; NW IN and Chicagoland, They are THEE BEST! thin crust, deep dish, or the dinners, it's all so very good! Yes, it's the sweet sauce which is my favorite! So,if you aren't sure about a sweeter sauce start way thin crust. But our go to orders are either a Deep Dish with extra cheese and pepperoni or thin crust with pepperoni and green peppers. No need to order extra cheese on a thin because they cheese it up real good! Glenwood location is better than highland in my opinion but if you're closer to highland IN location, they're good too,but worth the drive to Glenwood. And the liquor store right next door is convenient to pop in on your way to get your pizza if it's a weekend and you need a nice cold adult beverage to go with your pizza!