Arena's Pizza Muskegon / WolfLake

Had such a great experience here! The pizza came out piping hot with generous toppings on every slice, you can tell they don’t skimp. Everything tasted super fresh, and the crust was the perfect balance of crispy and chewy. The service was also amazing; friendly, fast, and just made the whole visit even better. Definitely coming back! 🍕🙌

Hole in the wall/divey type pizza joint. Ordered take out over phone, nothing special. I got there to pick up the Stromboli and the boxes wouldn’t close. Because it was so huge! Best Stromboli I’ve ever had. Guy on the phone told me that one would feed two people. My family of two adults and two small children finished one the night of and the second one the next day. I can’t wait to go back. I’m getting hungry now writing this review.

We ordered 2 18in pizzas. It cost 53$. One of the pizzas was a pepperoni and mushroom, they gave us a pepperoni and bacon. On top of being the wrong order the taste was off. The pepperoni was very spicy, the sauce was not good. The ham chunks on our Hawaiian were huge and had the skin attached. Some of the bacon pieces were grey and fatty and it did not taste good at all. Very disappointed. Had great ratings on Google, but tonight they fell short. We waited an hour for the pizza to be delivered and we still tipped 20$. We will definitely not be back.

Truly was one of the best cheesy bread sticks you can get in Muskegon. The pizza itself was hot and loaded with cheese. I'm tellin' ya If you love cheese then you'll love Arenas. Also, $26 for the large pepperoni pizza and a order of family cheese sticks is affordable in my book. All in all of you're a first time customer like me, who has heard mixed reviews, I'd definitely recommend trying for yourself.

I ordered a normal cheese pizza. What I got was a pound of cheese with very little sauce and some dough. The ratios are all over the place. I did also order a meatball sub, the sub was alright.