Arcaro's Pizza

Absolutely love this place and never disappoints. It’s one of the unique different types of pizza places. They offer a cozy relaxing bar to stop in for a drink or bring the family for pizza.

I will start by saying pizza is still the same and was very good. Our waitress was well not so friendly but not a big deal! We decided to order a dozen of clams which were14.95$ “market price “they were like the size of a dime . Heads up stick with the pizza and you won’t be disappointed. I won’t be rushing back anytime soon.

The server was very friendly and knowledgeable of menu. My friends could not stop talking about the tacos. We shared the white pizza and added broccoli. It was very tasty. If you prefer crisp crust, order your pizza extra crispy.

Great restaurant for Old Forge Pizza and so much more! Full menu, full bar, friendly atmosphere. A well loved placed for great food for decades.

Pizza 12 cut regular was good , but better options near by. Some cuts were better than others. Some were dry,some were creamy cheese sauce. The good cuts were definitely good.