Anthony's & Mario's Family

Ordered a Grandma pizza, first time there. Pizza did not resemble or taste like any grandma pizza I ever had. The crust looked like a frozen pie. Taste was not good. Kid was friendly and attentive at the register.

We just moved to North Haledon and were very excited to try out the local restaurants. The prices at Anthony’s and Mario’s are reasonable and the pizza was ready quickly, but the pie itself tasted a little bland. The large cheese pie was $10 and we were charged $2 for the pepperoni on the half. There was also an additional 3.5% surcharge for using a credit card. So overall it does add up, but still not as expensive as other places that we’ve been to.

Food is good. Prices are great & customer service on point!

Here the thing about this place, the food is good and the prices are great. Good pizza - better than some of the small chains in the area and at a better place. It's a small local place and it emphasis the value of eating local.

Hair literally cooked into the pizza, when confronted about it he denied everything and his justification is that he's bald lol. Gave me a lot of pushback instead of just apologizing right away and making another pie. Never ordering from here again