Anthony's at Squalicum Harbor

The food was amazing! Went for our 20th anniversary and felt quite special! Got a gift card with a free appetizer to come back! Everything just felt good throughout the evening! I will definitely be going back! Also the bathrooms, at least I know for the girls, but the private stalls with the sink, loved it!

Oyster appetizers were fresh and yummy! I got my drink and apps very quickly. Dinner came out at a reasonable time, but I was disappointed by the plating. The entree was $36 but the way the food was plated made it look incomplete and low quality. Potato and broccoli sides were cold. Steak was cooked perfectly! Mushrooms were delicious. A few small tweaks and a little training and this would have been a 5 start dinner.

Extremely disappointed. Food tastes ok. I asked for MEDIUM RARE. My steak was fully cooked and the waitress did that on purpose. She was completely rude to me the WHOLE time but not towards my friend. The cake she gave him that we also shared for his birthday was also extremely disgusting. And burnt bread?! Not to mention she kept going to everyone’s table but ours. We were waiting forever. I could have asked my steak to be recooked but I waited SO long the first time, I didn’t want to wait longer (and she never came by our table!! Not surprising!!). Prolly had to do with me being black and her being a sad white waitress. Not a me issue. Get better servers that don’t have a race complex.

For the money spent, the portions could be way better. The baked oysters on app menu were the worst of it. You got 4 for 18.00 and they were the tiniest oysters we ever have seen that came with a tiny fork. All total, you maybe got 2 bites out of 4 oysters. Not happy. Won't go back. The money spent needs to be fair. Wished we took pic of oysters. When thrley came out, hubs thought he was in a hidden camera show. Lol.

We love Anthony’s and are never disappointed. We were in for Sunset Dinner on 2/13/26 and had a wonderful dinner and our server was Kelsie who was very pleasant and professional. See you next time!!