Annie's Custard & Cafe

Here’s a polished 5-star review you can post for Fresh Custard and Café: ⸻ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Absolutely incredible food and experience! We stumbled upon Annie’s Fresh Custard and Café and were completely blown away. The paninis were perfectly grilled and packed with flavor — we it paired with the Tuscan salad, it was a fresh and delicious combo. We also had breakfast, and every bite was amazing! The biscuits and gravy were rich and comforting, the rosemary potatoes were crispy and flavorful, and the star of the show? The cinnamon roll called a “Wagon Wheel” — warm, gooey, and absolutely unforgettable. The service was friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere was cozy. We can’t wait to come back! Added bonus owner was beyond friendly and knows exactly how to make you welcomed. Most kindest p

We stopped in to try their custard, and was happy to see other great things on the menu, as well. Everyone loved their custard, and my daughter liked hers so much she was begging to go back later that day for more. She finished 4 scoops of strawberry and loved every spoonful that day! I decided to try the Tuscan salad and absolutely loved it! One of the best salads I've ever had! When we went back that night for more custard for my daughter, we decided to take two more salads to go. The owners were very kind and put a lot of love into their food. I wish we lived closer so we could eat here all the time! Highly recommend!!

Excellent customer service, excellent custard. Two awesome workers took care of nine orders of custard, multiple scoops were flying out of the cooler in a neat and professional fashion. Brought back memories of the good old times. If you are visiting Nauvoo and you are a human being you should visit Annie's custard! I'm glad they had a non-dairy flavor, and delicious seasonal flavors!

In August 2025, we visited Annie's Custard & Cafe in Nauvoo, Illinois. We were in Nauvoo for the Nauvoo Pageant, a theatrical production that happens nightly during the Summer. We ordered Panini sandwiches and the food was delicious. The Nauvoo Pageant was great, and thank you to Annie's Custard & Cafe for our delicious dinner before the Nauvoo Pageant.

My wife and I came for custard ice cream at the end of the day and were so impressed, we came back the following morning for breakfast! We had the delicious Midwestern Skillet and spectacular 9:37 Waffle. (Named after the time when original owners would close the doors) We even bought the day old cinnamon roll, because it was the last in the case before closing and it did NOT disappoint! We ate it, even though we were not hungry. We LOVED it all!!