Andy's Sub Shop

Honestly I used to love this place…… But the lack of signs and explanation or questions from workers when ordering subs ended up with my 6 year old having hot pepper relish on her sub. I only ordered a turkey sub with mayo, cheese, lettuce, tomato.

Andy's is under new ownership and moved to 100 loader st. I eat there today. The taste of the ham sub took me in time to when I would order all the time when I was younger... Same great taste... It is 100% spot on !! I am truly a big fan....

Love their subs,salad and brownies. The staff is always friendly and quick to get your food prepared for you.

Unfortunately, I was not impressed with the Andy's sub I received. The "whole sub" was only 10" long. It wasn't even big enough to share with my husband. I basically paid $12 for a half sub! The roll wasn't very soft at all. I was told the roast beef was med rare, and as you can see it was anything but. There was hardly any meat on it at all also. As anyone from this area knows, Andy's has had a reputation for years in Hornell for the best subs! Unfortunately, the new owners haven't quite lived up to the reputation. I'll definitely be trying them again after giving them time to work it out.

Absolutely delicious! This is a HUGE upgrade from their last location. Andy's staff are very kind and accommodating. If you wan a real, quality sub, forget Subway or Wegmans. Andy's Sub Shop is the place to go!