Andy's Frozen Custard

I got one of their caramel apples today and came home to find it was a totally rotten apple. When I’m paying close to $10 for a caramel apple I expect it to be fresh and edible. Very disappointed. Update: I originally had a 1 star but the customer service was amazing and very helpful! They definitely have made it right. The care for the consumer is very appreciated!

Andy's custard is phenominal - love their flavor even so plain without any toppings! Great drive by or our door seating late-night snack.

At night shift On August 27, 2025, I had a really disappointing experience here. We ordered a banana split, but the girl at the counter charged us for a double banana instead. Her attitude was extremely rude, which was very upsetting. All the other staff I’ve interacted with in the past have such a nice attitude they’re polite and explain things kindly if something isn’t available. But this girl was the opposite. We simply asked for a normal order double banana and banana split something I order everywhere else without an issue. Instead, she messed up the order, charged for double banana, and only gave us one banana, not even in the correct cup. It honestly made no sense. If she doesn’t want to work, she shouldn’t be treating customers poorly. The owner really needs to pay attention to h

They had a wide variety of choices so everyone was able to pick exactly what they wanted. Prices were fair and reasonable, the custard was excellent, and service was fast and friendly. Very kid friendly and everyone was happy. Will happily visit again.

Service was fast, and the custard was good but I got a medium and my custard from the top of it to the top of cup was 2 inches for $8.43.. Usually the cup is almost full.