Andy's Frozen Custard

Amazing custard and cool staff. It took me a minute my first time here. Ended settling on the lemon bar custard. Custard was great. It was huge. Very strong lemon flavor. I think I should have just gotten a regular one. Fun place for sure and definitely going to be back to try more flavors.

Towed our car after 5 minutes with 20+ other empty spots in their lot. $322 bill. Emailed the manager, Natalie, and asked if she could do anything for us. Said she would talk to tow truck company and then hasn’t responded to our follow up. You’re never getting my business again, Andy's!

Andy’s frozen custard since 1986! That’s a good year 😉With so many different custard options it’s no wonder they been open so long. The custard is amazing. Some didn’t even make it the drive home they were finished in the car 🍦🍨🚙 We tried to order smalls but they came out bigger than expected but no worries it didn’t go to waste we enjoyed every last drop. The staff was friendly we didn’t know what we wanted and the cashier was patiently waiting on us! I look forward to returning and trying out some more menu options. I love how you can view through the window and watch the custard being made.

Andy’s Frozen Custard Excellent experience from start to finish. The staff was very friendly, efficient, and clearly takes pride in what they do. I ordered the Snow Monster, and if you like strawberry and chocolate, it’s a no-brainer — absolutely solid. Product quality was top-tier and consistent. Their app is actually worth downloading: points on every purchase, a free treat after your first visit, $5 rewards, double points on seasonal items, a birthday reward, referral bonuses, and early access to new treats. From a business standpoint, it’s a smart loyalty program that rewards repeat customers. Well-run operation and definitely a place I’ll continue to support.

My first time trying this place and I liked it.