American Pie Pizzeria Southampton

Our pizza was great, the restaurant was clean and the service was above and beyond expectations. The Brooklyn and Taco slices were excellent. The owner came to our table and chatted for a while like we were old friends. After my husband said his slice would’ve been even better with extra sauce, the owner brought out another slice with extra sauce plus plenty of sauce to take home, all free of charge. We will definitely be back.

This is one of the best pizzeria I have been to. From the food, which is delicious and plentiful. The service is over the top; attentive, friendly as well as extremely helpful. Also, the person who oversee the place Raj is awesome. He makes you feel like you are family. I can see why people continually keeps going back. The atmosphere is bright and cheery, and the entire place is spotless. I recommend anyone traveling out east or lives in the vicinity stop by and you will see with your own eyes what I mean.

This is the best pizza place in Southampton. Owners and staff are awesome. Place is clean and air conditioned and well lit. The pie is great and there’s always an incredible variety. Super generous with the toppings AND they deliver.

American Pie Pizzeria Southampton has the best white/broccoli pizza I've had. I also enjoyed the Brooklyn slice ! The people there are very nice and welcoming. They use unbleached flour and fresh toppings. I'm definitely going back, the next time I'm in Southampton .

Wowwwww! I was a frequent patron for American Pie in Bridgehampton till I moved to Westampton Beach. Was in search for a gluten free pie and stumbled on this location not even realizing the connection! BEST zesty sauce, amazing flavor & awesome crew of friendly people! The kind of place you feel happy to be loyal to. They got me!!!!!!!