American Pie Pizzeria - Bridgehampton

Love this place!!! Even after I moved to Shirley this is still the best pizzeria!! The only place to go for a good calzone. Fresh quality ingredients and great staff! 10/10!

I ordered delivery from American Pie of the Hamptons and the experience was excellent 🍕 The food always arrives hot, well packaged, and super delicious. The crust is amazing and the ingredients taste fresh. Plus, the delivery service is always on time.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ American Pie is Back — and Better Than Ever in Southampton! American Pie has officially made its return, and we couldn’t be happier to see it now in Southampton! The pasta and pizza were incredibly fresh and absolutely delicious — every bite was full of flavor. It’s the perfect spot for families looking for a casual night out or adults craving a satisfying, hearty meal. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the food hits the mark. Definitely a new favorite in town — we’ll be back soon!

The meatball parm I got was delicious! Very tasty sauce, bread was perfectly toasted and even the meatballs on their own were good! The service was attentive and friendly. Only negative part about my experience was the seats being so close to the door but otherwise it was perfect! Great place to go for lunch after a long day!

Staff made joke that didnt land several times. Got a meatball roll, tastes like sausage. Didn't cut it in half and the dough was raw. Thought it was stretchy mozzarella but nope its cold. Raw dough. Not cool.