American 35

I had a fantastic experience at American 35 while visiting the area for work. Now, let’s talk about the food—everything I tried was amazing, but the pizza was the real standout. Each slice was perfectly cooked with a crispy crust and flavorful toppings that left me wanting more. It's definitely one of the best pizzas I've had!

Was craving a good brick oven pizza and decided to go to Waitsburg and check this place out after looking it up on Google maps. Got there and the place was empty and it looked like it had just been remodeled, very nicely I might add. Ordered a craft your own pizza with pepperoni, onions and bacon. Shortly after the place filled up quick and the waitress Lisa was super busy, however she did an excellent job with a great attitude.. the pizza was very good however it would have been 5 stars if it would have been Canadian Bacon but they don't offer that topping. Had the Basque Cheesecake for dessert and it was really good as well but could have been 5 stars if it had Carmel drizzled on it. I would definitely recommend stopping by and checking it out for yourself sometime.. I will be back to

This place is great! So excited to have this gem here in Waitsburg. The food was excellent and the service is wonderful! We had the warmed olives and the Mama Lil’s pizza. I’m not usually a fan of olives but would definitely order again. As for the Mama Lil’s pizza, this is quickly becoming my go-to for this place! Just the right amount of spice and packed full of flavor. I love the atmosphere here, and the owner makes you feel like a friend when he speaks to you. We’ll definitely be back!

Wow this place is such a gem - amazing pizza, super fresh salads and veggie dishes. You would not expect food of this quality in the middle of nowhere, but I would drive from Walla Walla any day to enjoy dinner at American 35. The pizza is UNREAL!

DELICIOUS. Such an awesome new addition to Waitsburg. Bloody marys and beer were so good, and the pizza is DIVINE. Gluten free crust is as good as regular which took this pizza place to the next level. Every ingredient used is done so with care and you can taste how fresh everything is. The atmosphere is the perfect blend of small town cozy and modern. I love the local Mary mix and how much time was put into making sure this place supports other local businesses. You should definitely make this place a regular stop. Vanessa gave us great service.