Alfie's Pizzeria & Restaurant

When you walk into a pizza place and it looks the way it does in the pics you know the pizza is absolutely gonna smack. This pizza was perfectly cooked. You can tell they use high quality ingredients and that they really care about their product. They have earned their high ratings on Google and yelp no question. Don't even hesitate, hurry up and go here. Remember it's cash only

I haven’t been here in ages, but the quality has not diminished one bit! I ordered two delicious slices: baked ziti + vegetable slice. Both were great, but I have a soft spot for a great veggie slice, so I had to order another! Come here if you value consistency and a dependably delicious food.

The family and I were looking for a good pizza spot before our drive back to PA. Our usual place was closed for the holiday weekend, so we decided to try this pizza place because of all the good reviews and was close in proximity to where we were in Hillside. Louie behind the counter is a great guy. Very nice and very welcoming with a big smile. The pizza was what you expect from a New York pizzeria. Crust is crunchy yet soft, nice little char on the crust to give it that blackened flavor after-taste, which is amazing. Everything from the cheese to the sauce made the cooked slice look like it was golden brown. The crust was also not too thin and also not too thick. It was the perfect size to get that crunch from a slice. I also ordered a sausage roll and garlic knots, which were also eq

Everything we order is always delicious, but the upside down pie is the absolute best! They serve the best pizza in the neighborhood and the family who runs it are the kindest people!

Alfie's Pizzeria & Restaurant, boasting 800+ glowing reviews, definitely lived up to the hype! We tried the All Meat Calzone and Tuna Wrap, and both were absolutely delicious—I couldn't stop until they were gone, hot and fresh. Be aware, it's a cash-only spot, but they do have an ATM inside. While the dine-in area could use a bit more attention to cleanliness, it's clear they handle a ton of takeout and delivery orders. The staff were a highlight—super friendly and full of jokes! Overall, a great first-time experience and highly recommended.