agnello's cafe

So glad to find this place before we were arriving at our family’s beach house. We wanted to have lunch before we got there. We got the turkey club and it was perfect. Delicious! They also have potato chips/pretzels and cold drinks along with coffee. The bathrooms were ok. Glad they had them though. There are a few parking spots on the left side of the building. I didn’t see a wheel chair accessible ramp. There are stairs at the entrance.

Grabbed a matcha drink and a Build your Own sandwich - both were pretty good and I appreciated the accessibility right next to the beach. Mostly wall counter seating. They shave snacks and baked goods as well.

Not to be dramatic, but the single best coffee I've ever had. Was heading to a friend's in Harvey Cedars for a quick trip and noticed it on the way up the island at night. Came back the following morning to try it before the beach - love that you order on a kiosk bc I was able to and extra espresso and make allll the mods to my sandwich with ease (sandwich was a very solid fine). Had to go back for coffee the second morning omw back to NY. Easy parking, friendly staff. Can't wait for my next LBI trip to go back.

I rarely write reviews unless a place really impresses me! This cafe is such a gem! Not only is the food fantastic but the staff is so friendly and efficient. I love the selection of food and drinks. The cafe also has kiosks which makes ordering super easy. The quality of food is what stands out! I can tell everything is fresh and made with care. The seating area is limited so I'm curious to see if they expand in the future, either way I'll be coming back each time I'm on the island! They also had a water bowl for my puppy inside!! Keep up the great work agnello's!

I’ve never understood how agnellos can charge $15+ for a sandwich and just give you 90% dry bread. Fool me twice, shame on me