718 Slice Pizzeria

The young lady working there was great but the pizza is some of the worst i've ever had in my life. You can tell they use really cheap ingredients. The crust was terrible, cheese and especially the sauce was absolutely gross. I don't usually write reviews but after paying almost $4 a slice for that trash, i had to do it. This place won't be here very long, guaranteed

I thought I would try Poppop's Pizzeria due to the excellent reviews. We had multiple pies ordered for a party. We ordered a Cheese pie, Margarita pie, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Greek Salad pie, Marinara pie and a tray of garlic knots. How well your parties are usually determined by how well the food is. I had a lot of compliments that the food was amazing and everyone wanted to know where I got the pizza. Thank you for making my party a big hit. I would absolutely recommend Poppop's Pizzeria to anyone. Great food, great service, very friendly staff. We received a lot of compliments and definitely would go back.

Just tried great new pizzeria in Ronkonkoma. Really clean place. Family owned and operated very friendly. Pizza was delicious. Had Margherita pie nice crispy. Very good sauce with chunks of tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and fresh basil. Crust was thin and cook well. Definitely go try it out.

I live in Houston but I happened to be on a Work trip to Long Island and I wanted to try Authentic NY Style Pizza. This place hit the spot! I actually found it by using ChatGPT 🤯. Super friendly Pizzeria with outdoor seating and the Slices were Excellent! 😎

Great pizza and personality is what to expect at poppops. I stopped at this jem for a slice. Wow, I am so grateful I did. The pizza looked and tasted amazing. The desserts were hard to resist. Absolutely must try. The proprietor, I believe, was Darren, i am not sure, but we had a fun conversation he was a hard worker and focused on the customer needs. Old school values and fun to talk with. A true breath of fresh air. If you're near the ronkonkoma area, take a quick detour and say hi. No matter what you choose, I'm sure it will not disappoint. I can't wait to go back and try the heroes and dinners.